My No-Regrets, Enthusiastic Transition to Driving an EV

, former president | August 3, 2018, 11:29 am EST
Bookmark and Share

It is summertime.  I want to take a brief respite from the horrific news that dominates the headlines and public debate, and let you in on for what many may be a secret:

Electric cars rock.

In February, I took out a three-year lease on an all electric Chevy Bolt EV (confusingly named because its cousin, a Chevy Volt, is a hybrid electric/gas car).  I’ve had the car for about six months.  Here is what I have learned.

It is really fun to drive.  Because an electric motor rotates with much higher variability than its gas-fired counterpart, it does not need gears. This means it ramps up very quickly and very linearly—no peaks and valleys as you drive up a highway ramp and merge into traffic, for example.  Similarly, the car uses “regenerative braking”—the motor takes the kinetic energy from slowing down or stopping and transfers it back to the battery.  This means that the car comes to a gradual, smooth stop when you take your foot off the pedal, and when you get used to this “one-pedal system,” you use the brake only for the relatively rare unexpected need to stop quickly.  Driving an EV is like ice skating rather than walking/running—easier to get torque when you start out, more like a glide when you are level speed, and a much smoother stop.

It is more, not less, convenient than a gasoline-powered car.  I installed a “Level Two” charger in my garage.  This required an electrician to wire an outlet for 220 volts (the same as what a typical dryer requires), and install a charger which I purchased.  I charge the car once or twice a week overnight.  Plugging it in takes about five seconds, and the charging takes between 4-8 hours.  When I wake up, the battery is full.  No more trips to the gas station.  It will go between 200-280 miles on a full charge, depending upon weather (cold New England days decrease the range) and driving (highway driving uses more energy than city driving).  Because of the long range, I rarely need to use public charging stations while on the road.  I’ve used them five times since I leased the car, typically to add about fifty miles of range.  This takes about twenty minutes of charging time, which I use to stretch, get a cup of coffee or answer e-mails.   For the most part, these public charging stations are strategically located along major roadways, and easy to locate and use with apps on my phone.

It is more affordable than you think. The Chevy Bolt lists for about $37,000, which is too high a price for many to afford.  However, there is a federal tax credit of $7500.  Officially, that tax credit only applies if you buy rather than lease the car, but many dealers will pass the value of the tax credit on in a lease.  In some states, like Massachusetts where I live, there is an additional rebate of $2500 which applies to purchases or leases.  The bottom line is that I paid $2500 down for a three year lease, got that down payment back from the MA rebate program, and now pay $240/month in lease payments.  At the same time, I am saving about $60/month in fueling costs, as electricity cost per mile is less than half of  gasoline, even in a state like Massachusetts that has relatively high electricity costs and relatively low gas prices.  And not paying for oil changes, air filters, belts, brake pads and many other maintenance expenses for a gas-fired car also saves money.

It feels really good not to cause unnecessary pollution.  It is a challenge to identify things you can do in your personal life to lower your carbon footprint.   For example, carbon-intensive air plane trips is a must for me, as my job requires a lot of travel.  And some other options, such as rooftop solar, are not viable for me due to the orientation of my house and surrounding foliage.  But according to the Department of Energy, the electricity I use for driving my car generates about 3500 pounds of greenhouse gases per year, while an average gas-fired car generates 11,500.  That is a difference of about 4 tons per year of emissions.  To put that in perspective, the average resident of Massachusetts has a carbon footprint of about 10 tons per year.  Simply shifting to an electric car drops my carbon footprint by approximately forty percent.  Or to put it another way, according to UCS data, I am driving the equivalent of a gas-fired car that gets over 100 miles per gallon.

A lot more work needs to be done to scale up and broaden access to EV’s

As UCS’s president, I was obviously very motivated to drive an electric car.  But going through all the steps made me realize that we must do a lot more to persuade and assist people who might not have my level of motivation or income.  Here are some of the most important barriers we must remove.

Affordability.  While the Chevy Bolt EV is not a luxury car, the price is still out of reach for many Americans.  And the $7500 tax credit, while very helpful for some, fully benefits only those that pay taxes of $7500 or more– i.e., families that earn more than about $63,000 per year.  Moreover, that tax credit only applies to new cars; this typically is not going to reach those of lower incomes who buy used cars.  And, it is set to start expiring for some of the car makers, such as GM, who have sold 200,000 or more electric cars.  A high priority must be to extend that tax credit on the federal level and expand upon it at the state level to effectively encourage moderate and lower income drivers to make the switch.  Many expect that by the mid-2020’s no such subsidy will be needed, as falling battery costs will allow EV’s to reach cost parity.  But we are not there yet.

Practicality.  What makes an electric vehicle super convenient for me is that I can plug it in night in my garage.  Yet many don’t have this option. To make electric cars suitable for a larger range of drivers, we need to make a significant investment in very fast public charging stations, located in convenient places such as shopping malls, libraries, town centers, apartment buildings and workplaces, among others.  Funding for some of those investments will come from the Volkswagen settlement, in which VW has agreed to settle claims over its fraudulent emissions testing by expending over $2 billion in EV infrastructure, outreach and education.  Some utility companies are also starting to invest in charging infrastructure, recognizing that the growth of an electric vehicle market will add business opportunities for them.  But governments will also need to play a role in making EV’s accessible, and will need to identify new sources of funding, such as revenues from a cap and invest program for transportation.

Education and One Stop Shopping.  It took a lot of time to sort out all the practical aspects of owning an EV.  While there are helpful websites, I still had to do significant research to figure out, for example, what type of charger I would need for my home and how to find a good electrician.  I was motivated enough to overcome those obstacles, but for someone who doesn’t have my level of motivation, having to figure all this out might make an EV a non-starter.  To overcome the hassle factor, we need to make EV ownership very easy.  For example, just as utility companies provide one-stop shopping energy efficiency services, they can be tasked with installing home charging stations.

The past six months of EV driving has been illuminating for me.  It has shown me that the technology is here now, and it is a pleasure to take advantage of it.  But what is needed now is a surge of political will to make the necessary investments to scale up usage, and a stepped-up commitment from automakers to build and market a wide range of EV’s that are affordable and meet the needs of all drivers.

Photo: Dave Reichmuth

Posted in: Uncategorized

Support from UCS members make work like this possible. Will you join us? Help UCS advance independent science for a healthy environment and a safer world.

Show Comments

Comment Policy

UCS welcomes comments that foster civil conversation and debate. To help maintain a healthy, respectful discussion, please focus comments on the issues, topics, and facts at hand, and refrain from personal attacks. Posts that are commercial, self-promotional, obscene, rude, or disruptive will be removed.

Please note that comments are open for two weeks following each blog post. UCS respects your privacy and will not display, lend, or sell your email address for any reason.

  • GCO

    Thanks for the write-up Ken, and welcome to the club! What took you so long?? The tech you write is “here now”, mass-market practical EVs, arrived in the US some 7 ½ years ago.

    When I first test-drove an EV (a Leaf), it instantly clicked: I was done with gas-burners. I switched. It was liberating.
    6 ½ years and over 80’000 miles later, my only regret is that I could have done so sooner.

    At this point I’m wondering though, maybe it’s getting time for me to sell it, so someone with a tighter budget can get to enjoy this tech too — and then likely never want a gas car again either.

  • Rick Murphy

    I’ve been driving a Bolt EV since March 2017. Today took it on a road trip that was just over 300 miles, which was no big deal with available charging stations. Stopped, plugged in, had lunch with the family and had to duck out to move the car so I wasn’t tying up the DC Fast Charging station. No worries, no range anxiety. Admitted that for a recent really long trip from DC to NC I rented a van, but that’s the value – I don’t drive a massive vehicle for my 30 mile daily commute, charge the car using solar panels, and get a short term larger vehicle when needed. Now it seems that the oil industry is comparing Gas versus Electric in a negative light, acting like gas arrives at stations at no cost but counting the worst-case environmental cost of delivering electricity against electric cars. (Including making sure they choose the worst, coal-burning highly polluting electric generating plants to make sure that electric looks bad.) Given that the majority of my car charging is free (13 kW of solar here), it’s a real net positive.

  • Steve:O

    I could not easily afford a $37,000 car, but that doesn’t stop me from driving an EV. I bought a used 2015 Leaf in March of 2017 for $10,000. Best deal I ever made. EV advocates don’t need to apologize for the EV list prices, just be happy to loudly champion the advantages. You never hear muscle car and pickup truck enthusiasts apologizing for their $30,000 to $70,000+ purchases do you? Why should we apologize for ours? Buying more new Teslas, means more used EVs will appear, and more folks in my income bracket will be able enjoy longer range EVs. Get shopping you rich people! Oh, and by the way, an 84 mile range ain’t great, but here in CT, it’s more than manageable. I drove 1,500 miles last month, only “stopped to charge” twice, for a total of 27 minutes, and both charges were free. Beat that gas guzzlers!

  • solodoctor

    Great to read about the ease of driving and charging a Bolt. My brother leased a Leaf for 3 years. He is now leasing a Bolt because of the greater range of the battery. He is very happy with it! When it comes time for me to replace my Prius, I will probably go to an EV.

    As the ‘the political will,’ UCS members need to vote for candidates in Nov 2018 who will support the continuation of the tax credits. We should contact all candidates well before Nov and indicate that this is a must of they want our vote.

  • Ron Budway

    Excellent description of the experience of owning a Bolt. It’s a blast to drive, cheaper than comparable alternatives (all things considered), and not ever having to pump gas is great. As far as overall convenience, I think it depends. If you need your car to do long road trips regularly you shouldn’t get an EV, not even a Tesla with their excellent supercharger network. Who wants to wait around for an hour every couple of hundred miles on a long road trip? But if, like millions of people, you live in a household with more than one car, EV is fine. The Bolt is a perfect commuter car that can also do some fairly long trips because of it’s big range.

    I think the ICE car that most closely matches a Bolt is a hot hatch, except that the Bolt is much quieter and smoother than any hot hatch. I cross-shopped the Bolt and VW Golf GTI. GTI was about $4k less (after tax credit and including level 2 charger install at my home), but the GTI is obnoxiously loud, has a clunky transmission, and has pretty bad turbo-lag (former Saab owner, so I know my turbo lag). The Bolt is just more fun to drive. That surprised me. When you factor in fuel, maintenance, and repair cost the Bolt is less expensive than any comparable car.