The Problem with the Environmental Movement

Alexis Goggans
, ,
UCS | February 20, 2015, 5:15 pm EST
Bookmark and Share

Believe it or not, I wasn’t always an environmentalist. In fact, I didn’t know about composting or environmental justice until I was 19 years old. I often tell people with a precarious smile that it was my undergraduate studies at the University of Colorado at Boulder that turned me into the person I am today. But my journey to full-blown New Age hippy didn’t start with “save the whale” protests or “save the rainforest” campaigns. It began with environmental justice. 

This post is part of the series
Science and Democracy: Community Voices

Image: Letizia Tasselli/Flickr

When I attended CU in 2004, I was one of roughly 500 African-Americans on a campus of over 30,000 undergraduates.  I remember my freshman year clearly—thousands of students in UGG boots, velour sweat pants, aviator glasses and down jackets swept the campus. And then there was me—a bright-eyed, passionately optimistic 17-year-old, desperately searching for a store that sold Black hair products and mesmerized by the concept of “trust fund hippies” and their casual display of wealth.

Touting the line

I realized early on that the hardest thing about college wasn’t the homework, but the never-ending struggle to find where I belonged. I joined the Black Student Alliance to counteract the Young Republicans’ Affirmative Action Bake Sale and to celebrate Black History Month, but always felt like something was missing. Things really changed when I took a job as CU’s first Environmental Justice Outreach Coordinator, and was tasked with increasing underrepresented student participation in Environmental Center activities. Little did I know, this would be the single most rewarding experience of my entire life.

While working as Environmental Justice Coordinator, I had the privilege of working with a group of wicked smart peers that would become lifelong friends. I spearheaded a three-part Environmental Justice Roundtable entitled, “Privilege, Accountability and the CU Community.” I also organized concerts for the national Climate Change Teach In and discovered my passion for conservation, resource management and community building. Most importantly, I started eating better, exercising regularly and began exploring my spirituality more deeply.

I spent the next two years touting the line between the Black Student Alliance and the Environmental Center. Which means to say, I spent a lot of time hiking, biking, recycling, participating in protests and taking the bus down to Denver to buy Black hair products.

Alexis Goggans (front and center) at the 2nd Annual Anacostia Trash Talk Earth Day Cleanup.

Alexis Goggans (front and center) at the 2nd Annual Anacostia Trash Talk Earth Day Cleanup.

Finding the “us” in environmental justice

The more I learned about environmentalism, the more I understood why the Environmental Center needed an Environmental Justice Coordinator. Not only was I almost always the only African American at environmental events, even my understanding of environmentalism was closely rooted to climate change and pictures of polar bears standing on melting icebergs.

Later, a friend introduced me to Van Jones and Majora Carter, whose thoughts on the “Green Economy” and “Greening the Ghettos” radically changed the way I conceptualized environmentalism. Their work demonstrating how solar panel training and green roofs can combat incarceration rates, decrease unemployment and increase access to healthy food was a no-brainer to me. Not only did this realization solidify my identity as both an African-American and an environmentalist, I quickly shifted my conversations with students from polar bears to the Inuit and from recycling and organic food to job creation and sweat shop labor.

I realize now that environmental justice is part of a larger discussion on racism and that similar to how war, poverty and sexual violence are often perceived as affecting “others” who live “over there,” environmental justice is rarely discussed as an issue affecting the 7 billion of “us,” who live “here.” I think about it this way—similar to a drop of water being absorbed into the water table or captured as runoff by a reservoir, toxic waste dumped in underserved areas poses a threat to surrounding communities and to those hundreds of miles downstream. This becomes an environmental justice issue when those who can afford to live in gated communities have the resources to purchase bottled water or move, while those living in the ghetto lack cars to transport bottled water and face housing discrimination when searching for a new home. Thus begins the vicious cycle of environmental injustice that can be difficult to break.

Get comfortable being uncomfortable

So what’s my advice for scientists, politicians, environmentalists and activists looking to heal the wounds of environmental injustice? Quite frankly, get comfortable being uncomfortable! Engage in meaningful interaction outside of communities in which you self-identify and don’t be afraid if you lack the vocabulary to have politically correct conversations. In fact, that probably means you’re on the right track. Know that sustainable solutions are built in partnerships founded on respect, transparency and trust. Most importantly, understand the spectrum of privilege and where you fit in it.

Do this and the environmental movement will become what it should have been all along—a movement to create ecological, economic and social justice for all of us on Earth.

Posted in: Science and Democracy Tags: , , , , ,

Support from UCS members make work like this possible. Will you join us? Help UCS advance independent science for a healthy environment and a safer world.

Show Comments

Comment Policy

UCS welcomes comments that foster civil conversation and debate. To help maintain a healthy, respectful discussion, please focus comments on the issues, topics, and facts at hand, and refrain from personal attacks. Posts that are commercial, self-promotional, obscene, rude, or disruptive will be removed.

Please note that comments are open for two weeks following each blog post. UCS respects your privacy and will not display, lend, or sell your email address for any reason.

  • Love Mother Earth

  • Richard Solomon

    Thanks Alexis for giving me a wider perspective on my views of environmentalism. Supporting ‘the cause’ in many ways over these last 25+ years I have been a UCS member, I must admit that I had not yet linked EJ to environmentalism.I will do so from now on, however!

    • Alexis


      I’m so glad my story was able to deapen your understanding of environmentalism! Perspective and depth are best pursued through meaningful dialogue and self reflection, so thanks for reading and commenting! I hope you continue to find opportunities to make connections between protecting the Earth and honoring the lives of ALL its inhabitants.

  • SarahDawn Haynes

    First- THANK YOU Union of Concerned Scientists for hosting this blog!!! I remember the days of starting this conversation on our campus. Wow, was it ever hard. At that time there were scant resources/ mentors to help us. Through Dr. Robert Bullard’s work, the principles of EJ from The First People of Color Environmental Leadership Summit, 1991, and Bioneers speakers (Van & Majora!) we moved forward. But a growing list of skills were needed to talk about systems of oppression, privilege, and the intersections of the environment- not just the ability to observe and measure air and soil quality, but the articulation of why those measurements mattered and to whom. Neither the environmentalists or the social justice leaders seemed to talk the same language, even though the roots of our problems came from similar sources. It was just as Alexis points out, the courage to be uncomfortable that got things going. The legacy of that effort is not to be understated, see what came of it

    • Alexis


      Thank you as always, for the brief history lesson on environmental Justice! I’m so grateful for the knowledge you have shared and glad to see the Environmental Center continues to raise the bar by addressing key issues that affect marginalized communities while protecting our blessed Mother Earth!